43. Facts found:  In a 15-knot breeze, Demented Dumpling was slowly catching Beer Delivery down the latter part of the run. When Beer Delivery was four lengths from the mark, Demented Dumpling was still half a length clear astern of Beer Delivery as shown at left.

Demented Dumpling caught a late wave and surfed into an inside overlap when Beer Delivery was about two and a half to three lengths from the mark. Demented Dumpling called for mark-room. Beer Delivery replied that his bow had already reached the zone when the overlap was established. There was slight side-to-side contact but no damage as Demented Dumpling squeezed inside Beer Delivery at the mark. Both protested.

.....
Ruling: The stories told by the parties involved left this committee in considerable doubt as to whether Demented Dumpling established an overlap in time. Therefore, Rule 18.2(d) applies and the decision goes against Demented Dumpling which claimed the late change in the status quo. Demented Dumpling is disqualified.
.....
Both boats also broke Rule 14 but are not penalized under this Rule since the collsion caused no damage.

.....
Case #44
return to Quiz Index